Exploring Central Ideas Across Genres
The Central Ideas and Details category is a cornerstone of SAT Reading comprehension. These questions test your ability to identify the main idea of a passage and understand how specific details support that idea. This blog provides an overview of the category and examines how central ideas appear in three major genres: literary passages, science texts, and historical analysis. Each genre includes a sample question, with detailed explanations and strategies to improve your performance.
What Are Central Ideas?
The central idea is the "big picture" of a passage—the author’s primary message or purpose. To identify it, you need to:
- Understand the passage as a whole.
- Focus on recurring themes or arguments.
- Avoid being distracted by minor details.
Overview of Three Genres
Central idea questions in the SAT Reading section draw from a variety of genres, each with unique characteristics and challenges. Understanding these genres helps you identify patterns and strategies specific to each type of passage.
- Literary Passages: These passages often explore human emotions, character development, or thematic reflections. The central idea usually revolves around a character's internal conflict, relationships, or moral dilemmas. Key elements include tone, figurative language, and recurring motifs that point to the passage's overarching message.
- Science Texts: These passages focus on hypotheses, experiments, and discoveries. The central idea typically addresses the significance of a scientific finding or the explanation of a phenomenon. It often involves linking specific evidence to broader scientific principles or applications.
- Historical Analysis: These passages analyze events, movements, or influential figures. The central idea emphasizes the broader impact or context of the topic, often connecting individual contributions or events to societal or cultural shifts.
By recognizing these differences, you can tailor your reading approach to suit each genre, improving your ability to pinpoint the central idea efficiently.
Sample Questions
1. Literary Passages
Literary passages often explore themes, emotions, or a character’s internal conflict. The central idea typically reflects a larger message or recurring motif.
The little girl sat with her feet tucked under her, and leaned against her father, who held her in his arm, as she stared out of the window at the passing people with a queer old-fashioned thoughtfulness in her big eyes. She was such a little girl that one did not expect to see such a look on her small face. It would have been an old look for a child of twelve, and she was only seven. The fact was, however, that she was always dreaming and thinking odd things and could not herself remember any time when she had not been thinking things about grown-up people and the world they belonged to. She felt as if she had lived a long, long time.
According to the text, what is true about the little girl?
Incorrect. The girl’s maturity is metaphorical, not literal. The text does not suggest she is physically older than she appears. When approaching literary passages, always distinguish between literal and figurative descriptions to avoid misinterpretations.
Correct. The passage describes the girl as having an "old-fashioned thoughtfulness" and a perspective unusual for her age. These details suggest maturity. For literary passages, look for words or phrases that reveal deeper character traits, such as "queer old-fashioned thoughtfulness."
Incorrect. The text does not mention her memory or compare it to other children. Avoid assuming qualities that are not directly supported by the passage.
Incorrect. The text does not discuss her ability to form friendships. Be cautious of answer choices introducing unrelated ideas, as these often distract from the central idea.
2. Science Texts
Science texts focus on hypotheses, discoveries, or explanations of phenomena. The central idea often involves the significance of the findings or the process being described.
Paleontologists have found a remarkable fossil of a dinosaur that had feathers on its arms and legs, but not on its tail or body. By comparing the fossil with other known specimens, paleontologist David Hu and colleagues have hypothesized that this dinosaur, named Liaoxiraptor, could be an intermediate form between feathered and non-feathered theropods. The discovery suggests that the evolution of feathers was not necessarily linked to the evolution of flight, but may have had other functions first, such as insulation or camouflage.
Which choice best states the main idea of the text?
Incorrect. While true, this answer is too narrow and focuses solely on the discovery of the species. Always check if an answer addresses the broader significance of the findings.
Incorrect. The text mentions insulation as a possible function of feathers but does not confirm this theory. Be wary of answers that overstate conclusions not explicitly drawn in the passage.
Correct. The passage emphasizes how Liaoxiraptor’s feather distribution supports new hypotheses about feather evolution, making this the best choice. Look for statements in the passage that connect specific evidence to larger scientific conclusions.
Incorrect. While Hu and colleagues compared fossils, the passage’s focus is on the implications of Liaoxiraptor’s feather pattern, not general diversity. Avoid choices that shift focus away from the passage’s primary argument.
3. Historical Analysis
Historical analysis passages often highlight the significance of events, movements, or individuals. The central idea typically emphasizes the broader impact or context.
Many intellectual histories of the Black Power movement of the 1960s and 1970s rely heavily on essays and other explicitly ideological works as primary sources, a tendency that can overrepresent the perspectives of a small number of thinkers, most of whom were male. Historian Ashley D. Farmer has shown that expanding the array of primary sources to encompass more types of print material—including political cartoons, advertisements, and artwork—leads to a much better understanding of the movement and the crucial and diverse roles that Black women played in shaping it.
Which choice best describes the main idea of the text?
Incorrect. This conflicts with the text, which states that historians have relied on ideological works as primary sources. Check if the answer accurately reflects the passage’s argument rather than contradicting it.
Incorrect. The text does not discuss what historical figures believed about women’s roles. Avoid answers that speculate beyond the information provided.
Incorrect. The text does not mention other historians’ views of Farmer’s work. Be cautious of answers that introduce perspectives not discussed in the passage.
Correct. The passage explains how Farmer’s work has broadened the understanding of the Black Power movement by highlighting women’s roles. Look for phrases like "much better understanding" that connect the research to the central idea.
Looking for more practice and learn more tips? Join the Study Plan.
Study Plan